GoHotelly
Guest house Check-in 16:00 · Check-out 10:00

The Amber Tree Inn

Highly rated guest house offering LGBTQ+ friendly stays at 4 Buffalo St, Lily Dale. Close to Lake Erie State Park, Cassadaga Lakes, and Dunkirk Lighthouse.

4 Buffalo St, Lily Dale, NY 14752, United States View on map
9.8/10
Exceptional Based on 128 recent guest reviews
Free Wi-Fi Free parking Air-conditioned Kid-friendly Smoke-free
What recent guests emphasize

Warm hospitality and immaculate comfort

Guests consistently highlight the welcoming hosts, spotless cleanliness, and thoughtfully decorated rooms that create a relaxing and safe environment in a charming guest house setting near key local attractions.

Guests often praise

  • The genuine warmth, attentiveness, and friendliness of hosts Frances and Steve, making visitors feel at home.
  • Immaculate cleanliness throughout the property including rooms, bathrooms, linens, and common areas.
  • Thoughtful, comfortable, and aesthetically pleasing decor featuring unique artwork and natural crystals.
  • A welcoming atmosphere with peaceful details like calming music and inviting common and outdoor areas.
  • Helpful local knowledge shared by the hosts to enhance guests’ experience of Lily Dale and surroundings.

Worth knowing

  • The guest house is LGBTQ+ friendly, contributing to an inclusive and safe space for all visitors.
  • Rooms offer modern comforts such as air conditioning and amenities for storing and preparing simple meals.
  • While accommodations are highly praised, the property emphasizes a peaceful retreat ideal for relaxation rather than party or nightlife activities.
  • Nearby attractions include Lake Erie State Park, Dunkirk Lighthouse, and Cassadaga Lakes, offering recreational options focused on nature and sightseeing.

Best for

  • Travelers seeking a calm, clean, and artistically decorated guest house with attentive and caring hosts.
  • Solo travelers and those wanting a safe, welcoming environment for rest and recharge.
  • Visitors interested in exploring Lily Dale and nearby outdoor attractions such as nature parks and historical sites.
  • Guests who appreciate personalized recommendations and local insights to enrich their trip.
Compare booking partners

Open this hotel on the platform you trust.

GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.

Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.

About this property

Welcome to The Amber Tree Inn

The Amber Tree Inn is a highly rated guest house located at 4 Buffalo St in Lily Dale, New York. This 4.9-star property offers a welcoming bed & breakfast experience with a focus on creating a comfortable and inclusive environment, noted for being LGBTQ+ friendly. Guests appreciate the inviting atmosphere and thoughtful hospitality of the hosts, Frances and Steve, who contribute to the inn’s care and cleanliness.

The inn features well-maintained and beautifully decorated rooms, many praised for cleanliness and comfort, including crisp linens and air conditioning. Communal spaces include a peaceful living area with calming music and striking artwork, adding to the overall relaxing setting. Reviews often highlight the attentive and warm approach of the proprietors, who provide helpful local advice and personal touches to enhance the stay.

Positioned in the heart of Lily Dale, the location is particularly suitable for visitors interested in sightseeing, recreation, and exploring the local surroundings. Nearby attractions include Lake Erie State Park, known for camping and bird sightings, Cassadaga Lakes, and the Dunkirk Lighthouse with its maritime museum and scenic views. The inn offers convenient access from regional airports such as Buffalo Niagara International Airport, about an hour’s drive away.

This guest house appeals mostly to travelers seeking a peaceful, welcoming base with attentive hosts and a supportive atmosphere. It is especially well-suited to solo travelers and those who value a clean, calm space combined with helpful local insights.

Summary compiled by GoHotelly editors from verified guest reviews, partner descriptions and editorial notes.
Facilities & essentials

What's on-site and what you should know before you arrive

The short version: what's available day-to-day, and the key practical details most travelers search for.

Most popular facilities

Free Wi-Fi
Free parking
Air-conditioned
Kid-friendly
Smoke-free

Not available at this property

Pool
Restaurant
Fitness center
Verified guest reviews

What recent guests are actually saying

Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.

JS
Jenny Shanks Apr 13, 2026
10

I've been visiting Lily Dale and staying at The Amber Tree Inn for many years. The owners Frances and Steve are two of the kindest people. You can feel the energy and the intention around creating a safe and welcoming space for us to stay in while on the grounds. I couldn't speak highly enough about the accommodations and their hospitality. You will love The Amber Tree Inn!

DG
Dorian Gudino Apr 08, 2026
10

I recently had the pleasure of staying at this charming guest house in July, and it exceeded all my expectations. From the moment I arrived, the attention to detail was impressive. Every aspect of the property was meticulously thought out, like the beautifully decorated rooms and the thoughtful, peaceful details in the main room. The cleanliness was spotless, from the fresh linens and towels, as well as the bathrooms and floors. I saw the hosts cleaning almost everyday. It was clear that they took great pride in their property and went above and beyond to ensure that every guest felt comfortable and at home. What truly made my stay stand out was the warm welcome and hospitality. They were friendly, welcoming, and went out of their way to make sure I had everything I needed, as well as giving me a personal guide to Lily Dale! Their passion and commitment shone through in every interaction we had. I really felt comfortable, which is especially important to me as a Latina woman traveling alone. I highly recommend this specific guest house in Lily Dale. The attention to detail, cleanliness, and friendly hosts made for an unforgettable experience. Five stars isn't enough - I'd give it ten stars if I could. Looking forward to staying here again! Gracias Frances + Stephen!

RN
Rebecca N Apr 04, 2026
10

It was my first stay in Lily Dale and I went there alone not knowing anyone. This inn was the perfect place where I could return to decompress and refresh between activities. Frances shared helpful tips that I used to get the most out of my experience. I enjoyed calming music in the living area. The building is spotless clean, such a comfy bed, and I was wow’d by stunning artwork and décor of every room. Her husband Stephen is super friendly and such a great dog dad to their cute pup. I felt welcomed and so comfortable in their home. Great coffee, too!

AH
April Heinrich Feb 17, 2026
10

Absolutely cherished my time in Lily Dale and at the Amber Tree Inn. The minute you arrive on their welcoming front porch you can tell it’s a special place with wonderful energy. Frances and Steve are truly special people and lovely hosts. Every aspect of your stay is thoughtful and well maintained. Additionally, the entire property is immaculate and calming. Having such a comfortable and beautiful space to stay in truly enhanced my time in Lily Dale. I hope to visit and stay here again.

LB
lori b. Feb 13, 2026
10

We both enjoyed our stay at The Amber Tree. Steve and Francis were welcoming and attentive, making sure we knew what was available to us including upcoming program and events. The room and bathroom was clean and comfortable and beautifully designed. Loved the artwork throughout the house and the living room and outdoor area was very comfortable. We highly recommend staying at The Amber Tree.

BB
Beth Bersot Jan 12, 2026
10

The host, the home, the atmosphere, the energy, was all truly loving, relaxing, welcoming, and comfortable. The hosts were gracious, always greeting us warmly, with smiles, and I just felt at home. The Amber Tree was so clean, fresh and full of positive energy. The Amber Tree is truly beautiful inside and outside. This is the second time I have stayed here and will continue to book my stays here. I highly recommend The Amber Tree Inn. Thank you for a beautiful time, conversation, and for taking such great care of us.

SK
Susan K. Jan 12, 2026
10

Absolutely beautiful house with lovely rooms. Super clean throughout and aesthetically pleasing. The decor is amazing, and the room/bed was extremely comfortable with an a/c unit which cooled off the room quickly. It has a lovely porch that you can sit out on. The owners are super thoughtful and have a wealth of information about navigating the Lilydale experience (sites to see, times of events, tips to make the best of your visit, etc.) They go out of their way to make your experience enjoyable, comfortable, and interesting. There are so many little, thoughtful touches they add to enhance the feel and experience of being in Lilydale. From the absolutely gorgeous artwork made of natural crystals to the large number and variety of spirit/oracle/message card decks you can use to get guidance, these things really added to my enjoyment... thank you! They also have complimentary coffee pods and teas (all the water is filtered). There is a small refrigerator where you can store any food you bring or leftovers. There is also a microwave I believe, though I didn't use it. I will definitely be back to Lilydale and would not stay anywhere else! Thank you so much!

SA
Sheri Aaron-Miller Jan 11, 2026
10

Absolutely outstanding in every area!! The Inn itself, is meticulously clean. Rooms are beautifully decorated and very comfortable. Bedding is a crisp white and inviting. Francis and Steven, the proprietors, reside on the premises, and are very engaging and helpful. You can’t ask for a better location, as the Amber Tree Inn is in LilyDale proper. I have stayed here for the past three years and would not consider staying anywhere else. Looking forward to next year’s visit.

Location & neighborhood

Where you'll find The Amber Tree Inn

Lily Dale, New York, USA

Based on sightseeing, recreation, and getting around

  • Buffalo Niagara International Airport 1 hr 10 Car
  • Erie International Airport 1 hr 15 Car
  • Bradford Regional Airport 1 hr 33 Car
Things to do nearby

Worth the walk or a quick ride

Curated spots travelers usually pair with a stay in New York. Distances are rough real-world times, not straight-line.

Dunkirk Lighthouse 833 reviews

Dunkirk Lighthouse

1 Lighthouse Pt Dr, Dunkirk, NY 14048, United States

4.7 · Historical Landmark
Lake Erie State Park 909 reviews

Lake Erie State Park

5838 NY-5, Brocton, NY 14716, United States

4.5 · State Park
Cassadaga Lakes 16 reviews

Cassadaga Lakes

New York 14718, USA

4.9 · Lake
People also viewed

Similar Guest Houses in New York

Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.

2720 S Kinney Rd, Tucson, AZ 85735, United States

Cat Mountain Lodge

Stay at Cat Mountain Lodge, a 4.7rated bed & breakfast in Tucson with free WiFi, parking, and close to Old Tucson Studios and Ar...

4.7 (84) View
21.5 Reconciliation Way, Tulsa, OK 74103, United States

21 1/2 Boutique Hotel

Stay at 21 1/2 Boutique Hotel in Tulsa with free WiFi, parking, and kitchens in all rooms. Near Philbrook Museum, Gathering Place...

4.6 (119) View
7498 Main St, Mackinac Island, MI 49757, United States

Windermere Hotel

Stay at Windermere Hotel in Mackinac Island with free breakfast, lakefront snack bar, and walkable access to Fort Mackinac and Mac...

4.6 (149) View
1551 S Sleezer Home Rd, Freeport, IL 61032, United States

Super 8 by Wyndham Freeport

Stay at Super 8 by Wyndham Freeport offering free WiFi, continental breakfast, indoor pool, and easy access to Freeport attractio...

3.6 (403) View
550 N Van Buren St, Milwaukee, WI 53202, United States

The Westin Milwaukee

Relax at The Westin Milwaukee, a 4.4rated hotel offering sleek dining, gym, LGBTQ+ friendly services, and close to Milwaukee Art ...

4.4 (1,000) View
1 Pureland Dr, Swedesboro, NJ 08085, United States

Holiday Inn Philadelphia South-Swedesboro

3.9star Holiday Inn Philadelphia SouthSwedesboro offers free WiFi, outdoor pool, and an American restaurant. Near Philadelphia A...

3.9 (831) View
2941 S 4th Ave, Yuma, AZ 85364, United States

Royal Motor Inn Yuma

Stay at Royal Motor Inn Yuma offering free WiFi, pool, and petfriendly rooms near Yuma Territorial Prison and Colorado River Sta...

3.4 (145) View
1737 Sumneytown Pike, Lansdale, PA 19446, United States

Courtyard by Marriott Philadelphia Lansdale

Stay at Courtyard by Marriott Philadelphia Lansdale, featuring free WiFi, indoor pool, LGBTQ+ friendly, near Elmwood Park Zoo and...

4.4 (717) View
Share your stay

Stayed at The Amber Tree Inn? Help the next traveler decide.

Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.

Your email is only used to verify the review — it won't be shown publicly.